Vandersteen Model Seven Mk II - Stereophile 06/2016

Vandersteen Model Seven Mk.II loudspeaker & M7-HPA monoblock power amplifier

John Atkinson,Stereophile Apr 22, 2016 - oryginalny tekst tutaj

I vividly remember a conversation with Richard Vandersteen at the turn of the century, when he predicted that the only audio companies that would flourish in the 21st century would be those that made products offering greater performance than the customer expected for their prices. Historically, the Vandersteen brand typified that paradigm, with the Model 2, in all its various guises, remaining a best-selling speaker since its launch in 1977. (Between 1977 and 1993, 80,000 pairs were sold.) I was surprised, therefore, by the appearance of Vandersteen's Model Seven, which sold for $45,000/pair when it was favorably reviewed for Stereophile by Michael Fremer, in April 2010. By the time the Seven had produced one of my "Best Sounds" at the 2014 Consumer Electronics Show, its price had risen to $52,000/pair. I wrote in my report from that CES that, with an LP of Diana Krall singing Joni Mitchell's "A Case of You," "the hairs on the back of my neck stood up, so powerfully physical was the presence of the singer in the room. The Naim/Focal, Marten/Pass Labs, and Sony/Pass Labs exhibits got close to the Vandersteens in absolute sound quality, and all were even better in some respects. But none were quite so musically perfect across the board!"
Driving the Model Sevens at the 2014 CES were Vandersteen's then-new M7-HPA monoblocks, which provide a high-pass–filtered output (above 100Hz) to the upper-frequency drive-units of the Model Seven. At the time, I made a note to myself that I would like one day to try these amplifiers with the Sevens in my own room. That opportunity came later rather than sooner, after Vandersteen had updated the Model Seven to Mk.II status.

Vandersteen Model Seven Mk.II loudspeaker ($62,000/pair)
The basic architecture of the Model Seven hasn't changed since Michael Fremer's review: a rigid, carbon-fiber "cabinet within a cabinet" construction with a minimally diffracting stepped baffle; a tightly packed, vertical array of drivers—a 7" ScanSpeak Illuminator mid/woofer, a 4.5" open-basket upper-midrange unit, a 1" ScanSpeak Illuminator dual-chamber tweeter, and, firing to the rear, a fully adjustable, ¾" aluminum-alloy dome tweeter; first-order, 6dB/octave, impedance-compensated crossover networks; and a push/pull, dual-aluminum-cone, slot-loaded subwoofer powered by a 400W amplifier with an 11-band low-frequency equalizer with user-adjustable low-frequency contour. The front tweeter, midrange unit, and upper woofer all use Vandersteen's patented, proprietary Perfect Piston diaphragms, which sandwich a thin balsawood core between outer and inner skins of carbon fiber, to give an optimal combination of stiffness and internal damping (footnote 1).

For the Mk.II version of the Seven, Richard and Nathan Vandersteen made a major change to the tweeter's acoustic environment, bringing its acoustic center into better alignment with that of the midrange unit, which in turn has meant less hand-adjustment of the crossover, to give a more easily achieved consistency in manufacturing. Other changes to the subwoofer driver, such as weaving the voice-coil leads directly into the spiders of the dual 12" cones, are claimed to permit significantly greater linear excursion below 100Hz.

The new version of the Model Seven visually matches the . . .

Vandersteen M7-HPA monoblock power amplifier ($52,000/pair)
This elegant but hefty monoblock—it weighs 120 lbs—is made in the US and is built on a chassis machined from a solid aluminum billet sitting on three cone feet. The active circuitry is carried on a suspended truss with damped elastomer elements sourced from Harmonic Resolution Systems (HRS).

The M7-HPA was the result of a partnership between Richard Vandersteen, who was responsible for the overall design and architecture, and engineer Dean Klinefelter, who designed the unusual, zero-loop-feedback circuit. The balanced input stage features two tubes, a 6N1P-EV and a 6H30, and feeds two single-ended output stages using NPN bipolar transistors. The loudspeaker is connected between the outputs of the two amplifier stages, neither of which has the usual emitter resistor. Vandersteen says that there are just five parts in the short signal path.

Output power is specified as 600W into 4 ohms, and, in another unusual feature, the output transistors are not mounted on the finned heatsinks that comprise the amplifier's side panels. Instead, a liquid cooling system connects the heatsinks to the metal blocks on which the transistors are mounted, which keeps the devices at their optimal temperature. The pump that operates the cooling system is very quiet, as it needs to be.

There are 10 separate power supplies—the M7-HPA is stuffed with electrolytic and film capacitors, as well as a hefty toroidal transformer—and the amplifier includes extensive protection circuitry that operates in conjunction with a rear-panel circuit breaker that turns the amplifier off, and dumps the energy stored in the supply to ground. A multicolor LED on the left of the front panel indicates operating conditions: steady green when the M7-HPA is in standby, flashing blue when it's turned on and as the operating conditions stabilize, then steady blue a few minutes later, when all is ready for music. Three other LEDs on either side of the central stainless-steel on/off button indicate fault conditions: orange for overcurrent, yellow for overheating, and red for pump or component failure.

HPA stands for High-Pass Amplifier—the M7-HPA rolls off the low frequencies below 100Hz with a first-order (6dB/octave) high-pass filter. This is not an amplifier for all systems, but instead is intended to be used to drive the passive upper-frequency driver arrays of any of Vandersteen's powered-bass speakers—including the Quatro Wood CT, Model 5A Carbon, and Model Seven Mk.II—and other brands of speaker when used with dedicated Vandersteen powered subwoofers. In an unusual arrangement that Richard Vandersteen first introduced in 1988, these speakers' subwoofer amplifiers reconstruct the <100Hz signal from the high-pass filtered input signal.

The M7-HPA's price includes two pairs of proprietary DBS solid-silver speaker cables made by AudioQuest, and just long enough to allow each amplifier to sit next to the speaker it drives. The M7-HPA includes advanced power conditioning, and AC power is provided by a long cord fitted with a 20A IEC plug.

I was impressed by every aspect of the M7-HPA. It seems to be as thoroughly worked-out an amplifier as I have encountered. For example, when you set it up, you must remove four internal bolts to free the amplifier suspension—in a nice touch, these bolts and the plastic transport blocks can then be screwed into the rear of the front panel, so they won't be mislaid. Although there is a handle at the back, there doesn't appear to be one at front—until you realize that the top of the inset in the front panel, on which is inscribed "Vandersteen M7-HPA," is actually a handle that allows the heavy amplifier to be easily moved. Again: Elegant.

Setup

Richard Vandersteen visited to set up the Model Seven Mk.IIs in my listening room. We did some preliminary auditioning and maneuvered the speakers into the optimal positions. Richard then set up a sound-pressure-level meter on a stand at the height of my head in my listening chair, and used an ultrasonic tape measure to ensure that the speakers were the same distance from the SPL meter. We played his "Vandertones," which can be downloaded from Vandersteen's website: 11 narrowband warble tones, one set each for the left and right channels, with center frequencies ranging from 20 to 120Hz, corresponding to the Seven Mk.II's 11-band equalizer frequencies. Vandersteen adjusted the setting of each equalizer band until it gave an SPL meter reading that matched his target response. The adjustments mainly varied within ±1.5dB; a few at the lowest frequencies reached +5dB.

With the low-frequency performance optimized, the next step was to fine-tune each speaker's toe-in and tilt-back. Vandersteen removed each speaker's grille, and plugged a rectangular aluminum jig into the grille's sockets. This jig had a bubble level on its top edge and a protractor at its base, and positioned a laser pointer in front of the upper-midrange unit's dustcap. By rotating this laser over the protractor until the spot fell exactly on the SPL meter at the listening position, the toe-in for each speaker could thus be repeatedly set. (Each speaker ended up offset 10° to the outside edge of my head.)

We listened to a variety of music, making more fine adjustments, until Richard Vandersteen declared himself satisfied and left to catch his flight home.

Problems

One of the M7-HPA amplifiers had turned itself off during setup, but seemed to be okay once it was turned back on. However, less than a week later, it turned itself off again and then wouldn't turn on.

I shipped the amplifier to Dean Klinefelter, who found that one of the three Vishay plate-load resistors on the 6N1P input tube had broken. The repaired amp worked fine upon its return, but six weeks later, the other M7-HPA failed in precisely the same way. Again, the problem was a plate-load resistor in the input stage; again, once the amplifier had been repaired, all was well.

These review samples were much-traveled, having been used at last fall's Rocky Mountain Audio Fest, and in subsequent photography sessions and dealer demos. "We have very recently discovered that this failure is related to an issue with the crating/packaging that the amplifiers ship in," Richard Vandersteen e-mailed me. "While they are packed sturdily and rigidly fastened to the crates, they are too rigidly held to withstand the constant shaking of shipping over a period of days as shipping invariably requires."
At the time of writing, the repaired amplifiers have been continually powered up for more than a month, other than being switched into standby when I am at the office. Neither has turned itself off or suffered any repeat of the failure.

Listening

Vandersteen Audio warns that the M7-HPA takes a long time to break in—the dielectrics of the internal components and the DC-biased cables take about six weeks to fully form—after which, the amplifier will reach its full sonic potential some 15 minutes after being switched out of standby. That was my experience.

When I had auditioned the original Sevens in Michael Fremer's room, the low frequencies had a somewhat disconnected quality, with an elevated low bass. In my room, the low-frequency warble tones on Editor's Choice (CD, Stereophile STPH016-2) were a little elevated between 125 and 200Hz through the Seven Mk.IIs, compared to the levels immediately above and below that region. Overall, however, the tones were relatively evenly balanced, and were strong down to the 25Hz band. I couldn't actually "hear" the 20Hz warble tone, but was aware of a pressure on my ears that ceased when I paused playback. This suggests that Vandersteen's subwoofer has low distortion. The half-step–spaced tonebursts on this disc spoke evenly, with good articulation, which was confirmed by the evenness of the bass-guitar lines in the Commitments' version of "Nowhere to Run," from The Commitments: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack (MCA/Tidal stream).

The Seven Mk.II's excellent low-frequency extension could be appreciated not only with pipe-organ recordings—such as my as-yet-unreleased recording of Jonas Nordwall performing the Toccata of Widor's Organ Symphony 5 in Portland's First United Methodist Church (24/88.2 AIFF)—but also with the awesome synth bass line of "Royals," from Lorde's Pure Heroine (Republic/Tidal stream). Some years ago, I recorded erstwhile Stereophile staffer Ariel Bitran's band; in the mixes of those songs, I tried to re-create the low-frequency magnificence of live rock. The Vandersteen system was sufficiently transparent in the bass that I could readily hear how the dCS Vivaldi kept the intentionally phat bass-guitar lines better differentiated from the kick drum than did the PS Audio DirectStream DAC, especially when the bassist drops an octave at the start of a phrase.

Moving higher in frequency, Richard Lehnert's spoken introductions to the "Channel Identification" and "Channel Phasing" tracks on Editor's Choice sounded uncolored. Dual-mono pink noise sounded evenly balanced, though if I sat upright so that my ears were above the tweeter axis rather than level with the upper-midrange unit, a narrow band of brightness became audible. But on the optimal axis, with my ears 36" from the floor, there was delicious solidity to the sound even when the recording was mono, such as the Wilson Pickett hit "634-5789," from The Very Best of Wilson Pickett (Atlantic/Rhino/Tidal stream). And again, the evenness and weight of the bass-guitar lines in this classic recording were impressive.

The Vandersteens' high frequencies seamlessly blended with their midrange. I usually kept the rear tweeter turned off, but it did add a useful degree of air in the top octaves with naturally balanced classical recordings or old mono recordings, such as Nathan Milstein's 1951 performance of Dvorák's Violin Concerto in a, with Antal Doráti conducting the Minneapolis Orchestra (CD, Naxos Historical 8.110975), which John Marks had recommended. However, when the recording was itself a little hot in the highs, as in Charles Dutoit and the Montreal Symphony's of Mendelssohn's A Midsummer Night's Dream (CD, Decca), the rear tweeter was too much.

But even without the rear tweeter, the Seven Mk.II's treble transparency was impressive. The improvement offered by an expensive AudioQuest Diamond USB cable over a Belkin Gold USB cable was distressingly audible, even when the latter was helped by an AudioQuest JitterBug at one end and an UpTone ReGen USB at the other!

When I sat in the listening chair, the Vandersteen system threw a detailed, precisely positioned soundstage. The central image with dual-mono pink noise was appropriately narrow, and didn't splash to the sides at any frequencies. Equally important, the system made recorded reverberation more apparent than I usually hear it. On my 2006 recording of Cantus singing Stanford's Songs of the Sea, from Cantus's There Lies the Home (CD, Cantus CTS-1206), the image of solo baritone Kelvin Chan hung there between the speakers, but the acoustic of the Great Hall in the Washington Pavilion of the Arts and Sciences, in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, was more evident than I remembered when I recorded this album there.

Similarly, the inspired conversation between Jon Hassell's trumpet and Jacky Terrasson's piano in "Suite de Caravan," from Hassell's 1999 album Fascinoma (24-bit/88.2kHz ALAC file, Water Lily Acoustics), sounded more distant. I can only conjecture that the Vandersteens' time-coherent behavior on their optimal axis allows the brain to more readily make sense of the aural cues in the recording to reconstruct an internal model of the recorded acoustic.

Speakers Alone

As I'd been sent a pair of Vandersteen's passive balanced low-pass filters for use with amplifiers other than the M7-HPAs, I tried driving the Model Seven Mk.IIs with my longtime reference amps, the Pass Labs XA60.5 monoblocks, adjusting the filters for the Passes' input impedance of 17k ohms. This combination worked very well, the amplifiers preserving the positive aspects of the speakers' performance. However, the mid-treble was a little more emphasized than it had been with the Vandersteen amplifiers, and the overall sound was both a little drier and a tad less forceful. There did seem to be a certain synergy between the Vandersteen speakers and Vandersteen amplifiers.

Amplifiers Alone

Although the M7-HPAs are dedicated to the Vandersteen speakers, I did set them up with a pair of KEF LS50s, to get a handle on their intrinsic sound. The amplifier's inherent low-frequency rolloff was not too much of a problem if I chose the music carefully, and I spent a pleasant afternoon with this combination of a $52,000 pair of monoblocks driving a $1500 pair of speakers. My basic impression was that the M7-HPA sounded sweet without any attenuation of the high frequencies. The midrange, in particular, complemented the KEFs' natural presentation of female voices. Whether it was Lorde's "Royals" or the late Lorraine Hunt Lieberson's 1998 Wigmore Hall recital (ALAC file ripped from CD, Wigmore Hall Live 0013), there was a compelling palpability to these ladies' aural images. I would love to hear what a full-range version of the M7-HPA might sound like.

Conclusions

At the end of the 1980s, my system was based on Vandersteen's 2Ciloudspeaker. Priced at $1195/pair (plus $220/pair for the optional Sound Anchor plinths) in 1989, this tower speaker typified what I quoted Richard Vandersteen as saying at the start of this review: The 2Ci offered greater value than the customer would expect at its price. And it still does—last year, I spent a pleasant afternoon in Oregon listening to the pair owned by Stereophile's longtime copyeditor, Richard Lehnert.

But with the combination of the Model Seven Mk.IIs and M7-HPAs—which, at $114,000/system, cost 95 times the late-'80s cost of a pair of 2Ci's—the concept of "value" is much harder to quantify. All I can say is that I greatly enjoyed my three months with Vandersteen's flagship system. The combination of true full-range sound, superb transparency and soundstaging, and a magically palpable way with recorded voices, is hard to beat unless you spend a lot more money. Which sort of puts the system in the same category as the Model 2. Sort of.